Persuasive e-Marketing Persuasive e-Marketing
Persuasive e-Marketing

Enough talk about declining email response rates

October 31st, 2007 by Carolyn Gardner

I am so sick and tired of hearing how email response rates are declining. There’s such confusion in this area and it all comes down to MEASURED vs. ACTUAL response rates. What’s the difference you ask?

MEASURED response rates are what you’re all reading in industry reports. These are the so called “industry norms”. When you look at them and compare them quarter over quarter, you will indeed see declining open rates. Can this really be true? Perhaps a little, but it’s a broad statement especially when you consider open rates which are taking the biggest hit.

I beg you to consider the realities of our e-world - i.e. email clients that are defaulted to have images turned off — this means we can’t track these opens since our little 1X1 pixel can’t be tripped which results in the reporting of fewer opens OR handheld devices like blackberry’s that view emails as text which again are not trackable for the same reason as above. (Wow that’s one hell of a run-on sentence! Good thing this is a blog and you can forgive me!)

In my opinion, we should seriously consider the value of ever tracking open rates. But maybe that’s just me. What do you think? Should we stop reporting this misunderstood metric and put more emphasis on click-throughs and conversion? Comments please!!

To me the ACTUAL response rates are what really matter and these can only be determined through click-through rates and conversion. Of course deliverability fits in here too. Long live deliverability for without it, we are nowhere (that’s profound).

In the case of e-commerce, it really comes down to sales. Success for e-commerce isn’t really about how many people open or click - it’s about how much revenue is generated! It’s about $$$!

Actually, what’s not about money?

Related Posts

4 Responses


Justin Palmer Says:

November 3rd, 2007 at 12:04 pm

I agree open rates are not the best metric to judge email campaigns by. I’ve run a/b test in which the open rate of campaign a was better than b, yet b resulted in more conversions.

Unless your primiary concern is branding, therefore getting as many eyeballs as possible on your email, conversion rate should be the first concern.

dj Says:

November 6th, 2007 at 3:20 pm

WOW! That was a lot of words in ALL CAPS!!!! Also, a ton of EXCLAMATION POINTS!!!

(fwiw - I agree)

dj at bronto

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.